Updated May 2026
User reviews of PlentyMoreFish.com
After reviewing dozens of user reports, the pattern is difficult to ignore:
many users describe PlentyMoreFish.com as a scam-heavy dating platform filled with fake profiles, stolen photos, romance scammers, and aggressive subscription traps.
If you’re considering joining, read these reports first.
🤖 Fake Profiles & AI-Generated Accounts 🤖
Stephen Giles: “Fraudulent using algorithm generated fake profiles.”
Martin Grindell: “Many profiles written so badly — presumably by some AI bot — that they are laughable.”
Matthew Donald: “The messages are from staff on the site who don’t speak English properly.”
beverly coomber: “They use AI to generate well constructed profiles with attractive but realistic photos.”
Multiple reviewers claimed the site appears heavily populated with fake or computer-generated profiles designed to lure users into paying subscriptions and continuing conversations.
If you’re tired of fake profiles, scam chats, and endless subscription traps, these are the hookup apps I currently recommend instead:
These are the hookup apps I’ve personally had the best experience with overall.
💸 Romance Scams & Money Requests 💸
Neil Davies: “The scammers will move you to WhatsApp and then ask for money after they’ve roped you in.”
Mrs: “Most work for the UN on a peace keeping mission in Syria and are widowers. I kid you not.”
fran: “They all ask for money and use false mobiles.”
Ron Pepper: “Girls with suspiciously perfect images refuse selfie and video chat then try to seduce gullible victims for money.”
Several users described common romance scam patterns involving emotional manipulation, fake life stories, and requests for money after moving conversations offsite.
🚫 Fake Photos, Catfish & Stolen Images 🚫
Peter: “Virtually every profile on the site is fake or a potential scammer.”
Lee Dickinson: “Loads of photos stolen from news sites and social media.”
Neil Davies: “I exposed over 30 profiles using pictures from Facebook, X and even escort sites.”
Dean Lewis: “One profile even used the picture of a dead porn actress.”
Many reviewers claimed reverse image searches revealed duplicated or stolen profile photos being reused across multiple fake accounts.
💳 Subscription Traps & Cancellation Complaints 💳
Crawford Smith: “They’ve taken two subscriptions in two days.”
Paul Reader: “They make it hard to cancel payments.”
Ben Green: “I have been trying to delete my profile for days. It just goes around in loops.”
Ron Pepper: “You think you’ve cancelled but they still find loopholes to put extra charges on your card.”
A major recurring complaint involves recurring billing, cancellation difficulties, and users struggling to fully remove their accounts and payment details.
⚠️ Poor Moderation & Scam-Friendly Environment ⚠️
Robert Hapran: “Moderators don’t seem to care.”
Peter: “Customer support doesn’t seem to do anything in response to complaints.”
Neil Davies: “The site administrators do not seem to protect their members.”
Several reviewers claimed the platform appears poorly moderated, allowing scammers and fake profiles to operate openly for long periods.
⚠️ Common Complaints Reported ⚠️
- AI-generated or fake profiles
- Romance scammers asking for money
- Stolen photos and catfish accounts
- Fake messages used to trigger subscriptions
- Recurring billing and cancellation problems
- Profiles impossible to delete
- Scammers moving users to WhatsApp
- Poor moderation and customer support
Better Alternatives To PlentyMoreFish
If you want hookup apps with more genuine activity and fewer obvious red flags, these are the platforms I currently recommend most.
View Recommended Apps
❌ Final Verdict: Is PlentyMoreFish Legit? ❌
Based on the reports we analyzed, PlentyMoreFish.com shows multiple warning signs commonly associated with scam-heavy dating platforms:
- Fake and AI-generated profiles
- Romance scam tactics
- Stolen photos and catfish accounts
- Subscription and rebilling complaints
- Poor moderation
- Scammers openly operating on the platform
- Difficulty deleting accounts and payment details
While some users may occasionally encounter genuine profiles, the overwhelming theme in recent reviews is that PlentyMoreFish has become heavily overrun with scammers, fake accounts, and aggressive monetization tactics.
If you’re looking for hookup apps with more real users and fewer obvious scam signals, the recommended apps above are a much safer place to start.
We keep these recommendations updated regularly so you can avoid obvious scam sites and find platforms with real active users instead.